Sedevacantist uk is a central resource for roman catholic sedevacantism in the united kingdom sedevacantist. Feb 20, 2020 true or false pope on that alleged irrational response quite simply we didnt hear about it at all until today from siscoe and salza doing some research online we conclude that the book in question is probably the sedevacantist delusion why vatican iis clash with sedevacantism supports eastern orthodoxy by john pontrello released in. Covering a vast territory with unique clarity, it surpasses every work of its kind and is arguably one of the most important books written on the postconciliar crisis. Sedevacantism is the position held by some people who identify as catholic that the present occupier of the holy see is not truly the pope due to the mainstream churchs espousal of what they see as the heresy of modernism and that, for lack of a valid pope, the see has been vacant since the death of pope pius xii in 1958 the term sedevacantism is derived from the latin. Jan 14, 2016 the video is a response to the soontobereleased book by john salza and robert siscoe, true or false pope. John salza and robert siscoe evade this obvious fault by inventing a special meaning for universal. The remnant and robert siscoe refuted on sedevacantism. The announcement of the forthcoming publication of this. Or false pope on that alleged irrational response quite simply we didnt hear about it at all until today from siscoe and salza doing some research online we conclude that the book in question is probably the sedevacantist delusion why vatican iis clash with sedevacantism supports eastern orthodoxy by. Siscoes book will surely afford much clarity to the reader. John salza, attorney and catholic apologist, who coauthored, with mr.
Again, i was also pretty sure that the arguments would be fairly easy to refute because of the mindset of nonsedevacantist trads to propose that there was a pope but he could be ignored. The remnant newspaper answering a sedevacantist critic. Tuesday 15 february 2011 who lies in a silent grave i. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza 20150802 john salza. Sedevacantism is the theological position of those traditional catholics who most certainly believe in the papacy, papal infallibility and the primacy of the roman pontiff, and yet do not recognize pope francis edit. Interestingly, rather than demonstrating that traditionalists fear sedevacantism, father cekadas remarks suggest that he fears traditionalists critiques of. True or false pope by john salza and robert siscoe. The room was so small that father barthe had to place his chair behind the archbishop. After all the books and debates though, it became clear that all of the various attempts by philosophers and neuroscientists to reduce the human mind to mere matter i.
Church militant sedevacantism debunked in a nutshell. That is why archbishop lefebvre never adopted this position, and even forbade the priests of. Nov 19, 20 refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza and robert siscoe. Previous objects of steves obsession have been chris ferrara, john salza, fr. In this 700 page tome, john salza and robert siscoe present material from popes, ecumenical councils and doctors of the church that you will never find on a sedevacantist website. True or false pope refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors.
Recently, father anthony cekada released a video entitled why traditionalists fear sedevacantism. To john siscoe in debate yesterday, i mentioned i know persons who never accepted it. Sedevacantism is the position held by some people who identify as catholic that the present occupier of the holy see is not truly the pope due to the mainstream churchs espousal of what they see as the heresy of modernism and that, for lack of a valid pope, the see has been vacant since the death of pope pius xii in 1958. It completely refutes all of his arguments against sedevacantism. Brian harrison, john vennari, tim staples of catholic answers, and others, is the heresy that the catholic church can promulgate heretical laws and decrees. Therefore, im publishing it now to prove the veracity of sedevacantism and the errors of those traditionalists who are in union with modernist rome. Autopsy of sspxbacked antisedevacantist book written by john salza and robert siscoe. Email correspondence with salza and siscoe the start. I have not really examined those challenges, but you can find them online. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors, by john. True or false pope refuting sedevacantism and other modern.
The dogmatic sedevacantist position is one that may appear as a legitimate solution to this crisis in the church the worst in her history, it would seem, but only to those who have not yet fully explored its ramifications or do not know her teaching well enough. The gates of hell and the gates of the church the best. True or false pope refuting sedevacantism and other. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza 20150802. Every so often someone from the recognizeandresist camp will complain that no sedevacantist has written a full booklength rebuttal of john salza and robert siscoes 700page whopper true or false pope refuting sedevacantism. Absolute clarity on the errors of sedevacantism after reading this book. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza. Salza and siscoe, coauthors of the book true or false pope. This video refutes and exposes the new book written by john salza and robert siscoe on sedevacantism.
Wednesday 16 february 2011 truly tragic the episcopal consecrations of the thuc line founders. John salza has no idea what hes talking about new feature article this is a devastating expose of salza. Steven speray responds to robert siscoe and the remnant. Sedevacantism is one of the many positions held by traditional catholics. He has posted a series of articles attempting to refute various articles ive written on sedevacantism and related topics.
The foundation of the salzasiscoe book, endorsed by bishop bernard fellay, head of the sspx, the remnant, christopher ferrara, rev. Again, anyone with eyes to see and ears to hear is aware of this. There are books which are very well written and even those which refute current errors, but of few of them can it be said that they will have anything other than a timely. Quoting directly from todays leading sedevacantist apologists, salza and siscoe reveal how sedevacantists have distorted the teachings of. Mar 18, 2015 he has posted a series of articles attempting to refute various articles ive written on sedevacantism and related topics. It seems that anyone who writes against sedevacantism will become an object of attack. What is really excellent about this exchange is that it exposes the intellectual and moral methods and standards applied by these writers in putting their book together. This nearly can be expanded as necessary for any argument. We receive many inquiries into sedevacantist authors, websites and videos.
In march of 20 a false traditionalist publication called the remnant published an article called sedevacantism and the manifest heretic by robert siscoe. With the advent, or near advent, of the new book by authors john salza and robert siscoe, true or false pope, the sedevacantist establishment is in a buzz. Anthony cekada and his disciple mario derksen who runs the sedevacantist website novusordowatch. In this 700 page tome, john salza and robert siscoe present material from popes. Its not that it isnt a superb book, the title of the book and the length of the book along with a general malaise about anything to do with the current state of the church and the current pope. Jun 22, 2016 posts about sedevacantism written by editor. This book provides an outstanding treatment of numerous modern errors, each of which are of great importance for us to comprehend at this time of crisis in the church. Do you know john salza and his strong refutations against.
It exposes his lies, his massive contradictions, and his errors. Aug 22, 2015 this book is for honest truth seekers and must be answered. True or false pope by john salza and robert siscoe jan 14 by joseph saraceno true or false pope. Maybe they are excited that their obscure communities will get some attention again and maybe get fresh converts. Antisedevacantism in the age of bergoglio video, jun 2015. The foundation of the salza siscoe book, endorsed by bishop bernard fellay, head of the sspx, the remnant, christopher ferrara, rev. On this page we present a slew of links to articles, blog posts, books, audios, and videos dealing with the subject matter of the papacy, sedevacantism, the false theological position known as recognizebutresist. Siscoe and salza have been holding out this book as a veritable textbook on antisedevacantism. Discover delightful childrens books with prime book box, a subscription that delivers new books every 1, 2, or 3. If they are advertising it as a veritable textbook, 2 requires that the book be published with the approbation of competent ecclesiastical authority. This book provides an outstanding treatment of numerous modern errors, each of which are of great importance for us to comprehend at this time of crisis in the. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors, by john salza and robert siscoe, 700 pages true or false pope. Nor is it like those of the salza, siscoe, and ferrara crowd that intentionally confuse, refuse to call a spade a spade, and outright lie.
There were many pious images, a pile of pocket books, two chairs and five cats that appeared to be everywhere. There are books which are very well written and even those which refute current errors, but of few of them can it be said that they will have anything. This book is for honest truth seekers and must be answered. For those who dont know, sedevacantism is the term used to describe the position of people who correctly. Sedevacantism the vacancy of the papal throne since the death of pope pius xii the chair of st. What they all have in common is a belief that the current pope, and usually several predecessors, arewere antipopes. Graces will flow when judgments stop the coming home. One need not formally join a noncatholic sect to be considered a public defector from the faith. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors, have been challenged by a number of sedevacantists. Despite what i was lead to believe, the nature of mind was still one of the most divisive, unsolved, mysteries of contemporary philosophy.
Maybe they are scared of what this book has to offer. Monday 7 february 2011 to lost sheep contradicting sedevacantism. This just in from, in this section, we will respond to sedevacantists attempted refutations of our book and articles, including those published by fr. In addition to defending the book, this section will also include articles. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza 20150504 john salza.
Interestingly, rather than demonstrating that traditionalists fear sedevacantism, father cekadas remarks suggest that he fears traditionalists critiques of sedevacantism. As for them defending bergoglio, this again speaks to the heart of sedevacantism. The book true or false pope by robert siscoe and john salza was hot off the press, and i am pretty sure i was one of the first to place an order. John salza author of the biblical basis for purgatory. Cekada had already analyzed and refuted many of the authors arguments in a june 2015 video, and continued with a series of articles and videos in 2016. John salza is the author of the biblical basis for the catholic faith 4. It is not the type of book against sedevacantism like those of the patrick madrid crowd which simply beg the question. Sedevacantism is a theory that has not been proven speculatively, and that it is imprudent to hold practically an imprudence that can have very serious consequences. True or false pope by john salza and robert siscoe catholic. A little catechism on sedevacantism society of saint pius x. A site about a new book responding to the arguments of sedevacantists as well as. As he only had two chairs, the archbishop sat on his bed and father barbara sat opposite him.
1475 550 1273 11 496 161 412 689 936 1094 289 879 835 1238 1500 1257 180 66 144 1034 1019 530 12 1309 192 1206 623 356 603 662 414 572 1217 1028 1374 1546 89 1031 71 1299 1021 128 1261 1416 744